Wine Pairing Doesn't Have to Be Pretentious
A sommelier's guide to actually enjoying wine with your meal
Olivia Thompson
Wine & Fine Dining
January 3, 2024 · 2 min read
Views
Likes
Saves
1. Le Bernardin
Midtown
2. Daniel
Upper East Side
3. The NoMad Restaurant
NoMad
Wine culture can be intimidating. As a sommelier, I've seen too many people order the wrong wine because they were afraid to ask questions.
Let's fix that.
Rule #1: Throw Out "Red with Meat, White with Fish"
This "rule" is nonsense. A light pinot noir goes beautifully with salmon. A full-bodied white can stand up to chicken. Judge by weight and intensity, not color.
The Three Restaurants Doing It Right:
Le Bernardin - Their wine program is flawless. But more importantly, their sommeliers actually listen to what you like. Tell them your budget and preferences - they'll guide you perfectly.
Daniel - The wine list is intimidating (300+ bottles), but the team is incredible at finding gems in every price range.
The NoMad - More casual vibe, but the wine-by-the-glass program is one of the best in the city. Perfect for trying new things without committing to a bottle.
My Pairing Philosophy:
Match intensity levels. Delicate dish = delicate wine. Rich dish = full-bodied wine. That's it. Don't overthink it.
The Best Value Move:
Ask for the sommelier's pick in your price range. We love when people do this - it shows trust and lets us show off a bit.
What to Avoid:
- The second-cheapest wine on the list (restaurants know you'll order this)
- Ordering by region only ("I want Italian") without considering the food
- Being afraid to say you don't like something
Pro Tips:
- Taste before accepting - if it's corked, send it back
- The markup on wine is huge - don't be afraid of lower price points
- By-the-glass programs have improved dramatically - don't feel pressured to order bottles
- Natural wine isn't better, just different
Wine should enhance your meal, not complicate it. If you're stressed about the pairing, you're doing it wrong.
Featured in This Guide
The 3 restaurants you need to know
Le Bernardin
Fine Dining • Date Night • Special Occasion • Michelin Star
Must-Try Dishes:
Daniel
Fine Dining • Special Occasion • Michelin Star • Daniel Boulud
Must-Try Dishes:
The NoMad Restaurant
Fine Dining • Date Night • Hotel Restaurant
Must-Try Dishes:
Olivia Thompson
Wine & Fine Dining
Sommelier Level 3 🍷 | Food & wine pairing expert | Natural wine lover | Wine Spectator contributor
More from Olivia Thompson
Check out more articles from Olivia Thompson on their profile page.
