The Definitive NYC Brunch Power Rankings
Where to spend your Saturday morning (and yes, bottomless matters)
Jamie Foster
Brunch Spots
January 8, 2024 · 2 min read
Views
Likes
Saves
1. Balthazar
SoHo
2. Jacob's Pickles
Upper West Side
3. Sarabeth's
Upper West Side
Brunch is serious business in NYC. After three years of weekend research (somebody's gotta do it), here are my definitive rankings.
The Elite Tier:
Balthazar - The French toast is iconic for a reason, and the scene is unmatched. Yes, it's busy. Yes, it's loud. That's the point. Go at 11am on Saturday.
Jack's Wife Freda - Mediterranean vibes, incredible shakshuka, and the best people-watching in the city. The rosewater waffles will change your life.
The "Worth the Wait" Tier:
Clinton Street Baking Co. - The pancakes. Just trust me on the pancakes. Worth the hour-plus wait.
The Underrated Gems:
Westville - Multiple locations, never a crazy wait, and surprisingly great brunch. The market plate is my go-to move.
Let's Talk Bottomless:
Look, I'm a bottomless mimosa advocate. Best bang for buck? The Smith - good food, solid drinks, reasonable price point.
The Hot Take:
Eggs Benedict is overrated. There, I said it. Unless the hollandaise is made fresh to order, skip it.
My Perfect Brunch Order:
- Start with coffee (obvious)
- Something savory as the main (pancakes for dessert > pancakes for breakfast)
- Share a sweet thing with the table
- Bloody Mary if you're feeling fancy, mimosa if you're feeling fun
Pro Tips:
- Weekday brunch > weekend brunch for avoiding crowds
- Make a reservation or go right at opening
- Skip the Instagram-famous spots unless the food backs it up
- Bring cash for tips - some places are weird about splitting cards
Remember: brunch is a marathon, not a sprint. Pace yourself.
Featured in This Guide
The 3 restaurants you need to know
Balthazar
Brunch • Date Night • Business • French
Must-Try Dishes:
Jacob's Pickles
Brunch • Comfort Food • Family Friendly • Southern
Must-Try Dishes:
Sarabeth's
Brunch • Family Friendly • Classic
Must-Try Dishes:
Jamie Foster
Brunch Spots
Brunch enthusiast 🥞 | Weekend warrior | Bottomless mimosa connoisseur | Brunch Club NYC founder
More from Jamie Foster
Check out more articles from Jamie Foster on their profile page.
